Boundaries I'm Keeping As A Writer
Not too long ago on my YouTube channel (check it out here, by the way), I shared my thoughts about Rebecca Yarros, the events surrounding the release of Threshing Day, and boundaries that need to be in place between readers and their favorite authors.
Here's that video if you haven't seen it yet:
To sum things up, a percentage of Yarros's fans weren't thrilled with the announcement of Threshing Day, which is a companion novella for The Empyrean Series and not a continuation of the main storyline, hence people wanting to know about Book 4 of Fourth Wing. As a reader, it's totally your right to feel disappointed by a book and voice those thoughts on social media.
What isn't okay is crossing an author's boundaries and hounding them, even harassing them, for updates about the next book in the series because a companion novella isn't "what you asked for." Especially in the case of Yarros and Threshing Day release events that were canceled after the sudden passing of her father, where you had a few readers speculating over what the death of her father might mean for the future of the series and for them as readers, or more or less telling Yarros to get over it because they want the next book in the series. This is all in addition to leaks ahead of the release.
It got to the point where some readers are now creeping into the comments on her family members' social media posts asking for updates; in one case, a user took to the comments on Yarros's son's social media demanding that she tell his mom that she "yearns" for Book 4. In researching for the above video, I also found out that Yarros had to pack up her life and move because readers kept showing up at her house—something I learned through a post about Dungeon Crawler Carl author Matt Dinniman having to do the very same!
Needless to say, it's not all readers who cross these boundaries. Many, if not most readers, are respectful. You'll hear so many authors share positive interactions with readers at events and online. However—and maybe this is just my algorithm—there seems to be a rise in reader interactions that aren't so pleasant.
All of this has gotten me thinking about the boundaries I want to keep as an author. For context, I'm what I like to call a not-yet-published author because I have various romance novel projects, none of which are published as of yet. But even though I am not currently a published author, a lot of the boundaries in this post are already in mind if not already in place.
My Day Job Is Off Limits
Fun fact, I actually wrote this into Project Scrimmage (actual title coming someday) because it's actually a legit concern I have.
Okay, not a fun fact, per se.
In Project Scrimmage, Courtney is a gamer who streams as a hobby alongside her day job working at an escape room. She has a small-ish following online, but she's been able to maintain a boundary; thankfully, on the rare occasion someone has recognized her at work, they've been chill.
That is until an NFL team's O-Line shows up at her escape room job for a team-building activity. One of the players recognizes Courtney because she's his sister's favorite streamer, and once a playful "look who I ran into" selfie hits the internet, it doesn't take long for Courtney's online life and personal life to collide.
My former manager once joked that someday, the escape room I work at will become like the Pirates of the Caribbean ride because Johnny Depp happened to make a cameo one time and that had people flocking to the ride on the very off chance he happens to be there again, and that things will get to the point that I become such a famous and successful author that my readers are going to figure out where I work and make their reservations because there's a slight chance that I'll be the Game Master running their game. Obviously, that's flattering. But at the same time, I kind of fear that.
Blame it on my fifth-grade class's overzealous D.A.R.E. officer during the infancy of social media, but I'm big on keeping my public, professional life separate from my personal, private life. That includes my workplace.
Many published authors still have a day job apart from their writing, and I expect that I will, too, whether that's at the escape room I currently work at or somewhere else in the future. I don't see myself being a solely full-time author for a variety of reasons (I get more into that here).
I want to keep my day job separate from my writing. And that includes reader interactions. It's in part a matter of personal preference, but it's also about my safety and that of my workplace.
Respecting Reader Spaces
Reviews are for readers, not for writers. You've likely heard that one a time or two. It's just one of the boundaries that needs to be in place between authors and readers.
I've talked about it in this post about what authors can learn from book reviewers, as well as in this post about ways to cope with negative reviews. Essentially, reviews are there to help other readers determine whether or not a book is right for them. They're not meant to give authors feedback or invite conversation, especially when the review is a lower rating.
That's something I do intend to abide by, but with a caveat.
I do think looking at reviews of your book can be helpful in some regards. Not so much as feedback on an already-published work (as I once believed). It's more about things like using positive reviews in marketing or social media posts or in a feel-good folder you can look at on the hard days. Personal use only.
That's not to say I won't ever interact with readers in my comments. It's about knowing the boundaries, what is appropriate, and when to stay in your lane.
The nature of bookish spaces means there might be some crossover. Writers are typically readers, too. However, there is still a line that needs to be honored.
My Writing Is Not For Generative AI
Generative AI programs have been a hot topic for a hot minute now. Issues like the environmental repercussions highlighted in this MIT article and the impact we're beginning to see in students referenced in this post from NPR are only the tip of the iceberg. There are also a whole host of concerns held by the writing community.
As described in this post from Duke, "AI models are trained on vast amounts of human-generated content from the internet – including everything from transcribed YouTube videos and Reddit threads to image libraries and the entire text of Wikipedia... As students increasingly turn to AI, it’s important for them to consider not just what the tools can do, but the human contributions and intellectual property that made them possible."
Although there are a few outliers, the writing community is largely against using generative AI in books. On a semi-related note, a poorly received statement from NaNoWriMo regarding the use of generative AI sparked the controversy that led to the organization behind the beloved writing challenge shuttering.
Spellcheckers are one thing. Generative AI is another.
I can assure you, generative AI will not have a place in my books. That's one boundary I am firmly setting.
And of my future readers, I kindly ask that you don't feed my work into generative AI software.
My Chronic Illness
I'm pretty open when it comes to my Long COVID. Part of that had to do with the fact that COVID is still such a new thing and we don't know a ton about it in the grand scheme of everything. I feel like it's kind of my obligation to be an open book.
I'm generally willing to answer questions about my experience, to a point.
People are usually respectful and just curious when it comes to my symptoms and how they impact basically every aspect of my life. Sometimes, though, the conversations start to feel like interrogations, and that's where I draw the line.
And up until recently, with the conversations about author boundaries in the wake of Rebecca Yarros losing her father, specifically some readers getting pushy about her writing the next book instead of giving her space to grieve, I hadn't really thought about needing to clearly define this boundary.
So here it is: my chronic illness affects so much of my life, including my writing. Between the brain fog, fatigue, migraines, and inability to concentrate, among other things, writing is so much harder for me now than it used to be. That doesn't mean I love writing any less. It just means it takes a little more effort and time.
In the future, once I have a book published, I ask for the space to continue working on the next without the pressure of readers asking for/demanding status updates.
Also, while I am open about my Long COVID (and PCOS and POTS and the whole lot I got goin' on), if I begin to get uncomfortable and express that, kindly understand that and leave it be.
My Loved Ones Are Off Limits
This one, I feel, shouldn't have to be said. It should be obvious. And yet, we have situations like we've seen with Rebecca Yarros's son's social media page, where her readers are crossing boundaries asking for the status of her next book.
Here's the thing: he did not ask for his mother's fame to be at this level. And, frankly, I don't think Yarros herself did, either. Not to this extent. He himself is, to the best of my knowledge, not a public figure. Certainly not in the capacity that his mother is. And yet, he's being roped into the chaos and having her readers more or less trying to go through him to get to her. That's just not okay.
I am going to be blunt here: my loved ones are off limits.
If I have a friend as my plus-one at a bookish event and you want to chit-chat, that's one thing. But if it's something like seeing me at dinner with a loved one, that's not an appropriate time to come say hey.
There are times when it's okay to be a little lenient, sure. It depends on the specific circumstances of the interaction. But when it comes to things like approaching my loved ones because of an apparent connection, that's a no.
To be blunt once more, use common sense and show some respect.
In the age of social media, readers have far more access to their favorite authors. There are positives to this, like getting behind-the-scenes looks at their writing process and staying in the know about forthcoming releases. But this perceived access can easily become a slippery slope past an author's boundaries and into unacceptable behavior.
Remember: writers are humans, first and foremost. Respect their boundaries.
Maybe I'm coming across as rude or arrogant in this post, and that's not the intent. My aim is simply ask readers to treat authors as they'd want to be treated, to know when to hype them up and when to draw back.
What boundaries are you setting for yourself as a writer? Do you have any tips for preserving them? Share your thoughts in the comments!











Comments